Here's a much-needed reprisal of something I "borrowed" from an "acquaintance" back in my freshman year of college.

Overrated

• Blaming the majority for the sins of a minority
  
• Slacker culture
  
• Cheap, frat-boy beers
  
• Ice cream (non-soft-serve)
  
• DVD commentaries
  
• Wearing sweatshirts to bed
  
• Electric guitars
  
• Acknowledging Valentine's day, either by buying/receiving gifts or by being bitter
  

Underrated

• Compassion, understanding, tolerance
  
• Getting work done without complaining to anyone
  
• Gourmet beer
  
• Milkshakes
  
• Reading
  
• Electric blankets
  
• String sections and vibraphones
  
• Ignoring Valentine's day
  

Edited at 8:12pm to add the italicized items